Saturday, June 29, 2013

Book Rankin' Extravaganza

It is impossible to choose favorites. Just throwing that out there.

Favorites from each genre:

Contemporary Realistic Fiction - The Outsiders, S.E. Hinton

Historical Fiction - Tell The Wolves I'm Home, Carol Rifka Brunt
Science Fiction, Fantasy, Dystopia - The Hunger Games, Suzanne Collins 
Nonfiction/Information - Burn Journals, Brent Runyon
Adventure/Mystery - Paper Towns, John Green
Diversity/Multicultural/Cultural Differences - Out of My Mind, Sharon Draper

Ranking (best first):
Tell the Wolves I'm Home - complexity of plot, character development, emotional draw
The Outsiders - Endurance of themes, relatability of characters
The Hunger Games - Exciting plot, has a strong female role model
Paper Towns - Great dialogue, humor, elements of self-discovery
Burn Journals - Authenticity
Out of My Mind - While not extraordinarily well-written, this book has a lot of great and relevant messages to convey.

Most likely to be banned: Burn Journals

There are a lot of very heavy thematic elements (suicide, self-harm, sex) woven through the book. There is also a lot of crude language - multiple F-bombs - and an occasionally very negative attitude from the narrator. I think parents/adults who do not take the trouble to read this book will balk at the language and dismiss the content.

Most vivid descriptions of settings: Tell the Wolves I'm Home

June, the narrator, is very adept at describing the world around her in a literal and figurative manner. The title of the book is also the title of a painting that most of the book's plot references at one point or another. The novel itself is really something of an artistic/visual representation of adolescence, struggle, and relationships.


Best book to stimulate research questions: Out of My Mind

The main character suffers from cerebral palsy, and several other characters in the book are afflicted with a disability. I think having students research these and discuss them would promote an elevated level of understanding and empathy. They could also learn a lot about inclusive education and its rationale.



No comments:

Post a Comment